|Option 1: Emmy Rossum|
|Option 2: Kate Mara|
|Option 3: Leighton Meester|
|Option 4: Tracy Spiridakos|
Your choice for who should play Sarah is...
I wondered if he was attracted to her. It wouldn't be surprising--her brown eyes were glittering in the glow from the fire, and her curly hair was a perfect tangle of seductive femininity.
(Zoe's thoughts on Sarah, chapter 14 of After The Ending)
UP NEXT: Riley Biggs
Want to be kept up to date as we reveal each nominee? Like The Ending Series on Facebook, follow us on Twitter, or check back to this blog page daily.